top-banner_Logotop-en-stickytop-banner_Logotop-banner_Logo
  • Home
  • About
    • Statement
    • Partners
  • Partners
  • Petition
    • Petition
    • امضا کنید
    • Pétition
    • Petizione
    • עצומה
    • Petición
    • #2096 (no title)
  • FAQs
  • Posts
  • Contact Us
  • i-support
  • Press
  • فارسی
National Internet Hoax? Pay Deflates, Prices Inflate, Goldfish Released
April 17, 2012
Workers Suffer, Pepsi on the Moon, Cinema Slammed, Families Seek Justice, Prisoners Endangered
June 11, 2012

Iran’s National Internet Project: Keepin’ It Clean With Censorship

April 19, 2012
Categories
  • Sanctions
Tags

Arseh Sevom — Claims that Iran will launch a “national internet” at the end of August, cutting off access to Google, Hotmail, and other external services, were denied by communications minister Reza Taghipour. He issued a statement denying plans to cut  access to the internet calling the whole thing a “13th of Farvardin prank” [the 13th of Farvadin corresponds to April 1] accusing “the propaganda wing of the West” of spreading false rumors.

Non Denial-Denial

Despite Taghipour’s non-denial denial, there was nothing surprising in the comments attributed to him. State efforts to control the internet and social networking are well documented and go back to 2001 when the government took control of access points. In an article on Fars News published six years ago on July 23, 2006, then minister of communications Mohammad Soleimani is quoted discussing the national internet, claiming that it would benefit domestic users by reducing costs. He also defended censorship (filtering), stating,  “Fundamentally filtering is the right measure…The task of filtering is to eliminate inaccurate information and libel.”  Soleimani added, “Using filtering tools, people must be provided with correct and beneficial information. The filtering system is a good system, and we have to acquire its science in our country.”

When asked to comment on the ministry’s denial of an end of summer deadline for implementing a national internet, blogger and computer engineer Arash Abadpour, who has been following this story carefully, told Arseh Sevom, “There is no shortage of people willing to inform the world that something or other is a hoax when it comes to Iran, just as there is no shortage of politicians and officials who claim they were misquoted or taken out of context. The national internet is moving forward. Whether it succeeds or not is still an open question.”

Summary of the State of the National Internet

Arseh Sevom has been following the story of Iran’s efforts to build a so-called “clean, halal network” for over one year. (More information can be found in RSF’s Enemies of the Internet Report and in a Global Voices summary.) What follows is a brief summary of the state of the project:

  • Construction of a national internet continues. If anything, the regime is even more dedicated to its implementation given recent proclamations from the Supreme Leader;
  • It seems clear that Iran has been getting outside support for the development of its national internet;
  • Many inside Iran have begun receiving text messages urging them to register for IranMail (http://mail.iran.ir/register/?module=new). Registration requires the use of a valid national identification number;
  • Bloggers and owners of websites are being forced to register with a national system;
  • NGOs are now being asked to register with a national network;
  • Internet bandwidth is controlled by the state;
  • 5 million sites are blocked;
  • 29 netizens have been arrested and some are facing the death penalty;
  • Justifications for Iran’s construction of a national internet are the need for “national security,” echoing the justifications for surveillance given by democratic governments.

Supreme Council of Cyberspace

In March of 2012, the newly appointed Supreme Council of Cyberspace met for the first time. The group was formed in order to ensure that decision-making related to implementation of the national internet was done at the highest level of government.

In an interview reported with medianews.ir, a representative of the council, Hamid Shahriari, spoke of some of the problems faced by the national internet project. He discussed “overlapping laws and regulations…the lack of a strong will within the government, and lack of clarity of who had the last word…” In the course of the interview he claims that the creation of a Supreme Council on Cyberspace was recommended by “an Irish group.”

Laws Must Bend

The Islamic Republic of Iran’s plan to create a national internet has been justified as a way to “uphold national security,” “safeguard the minds of youth” from “corrupting Western values,” and give the Iranian Cyber Army an edge in the soft war, according to Ayatollah Khamenei.  Formation of the council was a step closer to shutting out competing online voices.

The explicit backing from the Supreme Leader has led members of the council to understand that Iran’s own constitution and law could not be used to contest its decisions. Council member Shahriar stated, “Laws have to bend before the stipulations of the high council. In fact what we pass is, practically, law.”

One Day You’re In, Next Day You’re Out

The national internet has not been welcomed with open arms even by regime supporters. One pro-regime blogger complained about the lack of transparency stating, “What guarantee do we have that filtering sites and news will not be done based on personal preference or political affiliation?”

Cyberspace as Public Forum in Iran

Arseh Sevom board member, Kamran Ashtary stated, “The internet has provided a platform for Iranians to practice free speech and communicate with one another in a society where the state controls all other forms of public communication.” Ashtary went on to note that the very size of Iran’s diaspora community and its ties to family and friends inside Iran makes it difficult to imagine that the nation could ever be isolated from outside connections even with the implementation of an “electronic wall.”

Iranians have embraced the freedom cyberspace provides. At one time, Persian was the third most used language used on the internet. By 2001, tens of thousands of Iranians were actively blogging. In October of 2011, the Basij claimed there were 17 million Iranians on Facebook.

Persian-language cyberspace has provided a forum to discuss taboos, sports, and even Harry Potter. In their article Iran’s Reformists and Activists: Internet Exploiters, Babak Rahimi and Elham Gheytanchi wrote:

“While the digital space brought to the younger generation the freedom to anonymously interact, exchange ideas, and write about sex and other social taboos, the reformist ulama began to use the new forum to discuss and debate political and theological topics of a complex and polemical nature that were deemed heretical by the conservative clerics. The target audience was not only the religious establishment; it was also the younger domestic and global audiences whose support would be the key to influencing the policy makers who would refuse them a voice in the mass media as it is strictly supervised by the conservative-dominated censorship machinery.”

Iranians were also among the earliest adopters of social networking. While most computer users thought of social networking as nothing more than internet dating, Iran’s former vice president Mohammad-Ali Abtahi maintained a profile on Orkut and by 2005 Shirin Ebadi had an online community dedicated to her work.

Do as I Say…

Anonymity and privacy online are quickly disappearing in democratic countries. Facebook and Google+ now require “real names.” The trend towards increased surveillance, online tracking, and the use of GPS poses a very real threat to people living in closed societies such as Iran. Democratic societies need to take a step back and examine their own policies regarding privacy and surveillance. Author of the report Legalising Surveillance, Regulating Civil Society (pdf), Ben Hayes, stated “The ability to use the internet free of controls and surveillance is fundamental to independent civil society. Unfortunately democratic countries are not doing enough to guarantee those freedoms domestically. With its data retention regimes, Europe now leads the world when it comes to regulations that encourage states to engage in surveillance.”

Recommendations

  • Keep up the pressure on Iran related to human rights and free speech;
  • Keep up sanctions against businesses and individuals selling surveillance technology to Iran;
  • Work with businesses to institute regulations against sharing surveillance technology with nations likely to use it to control their populations;
  • Support satellite internet connections;
  • Develop more lightweight tools and sites that do not require high bandwidth;
  • Remember, even activists and opposition love a video of a dancing bird every once in awhile — fun is key;
  • Keep the gatekeepers busy decoding recipes and other chit chat through ubiquitous use of encryption. Security expert Pete Bagnall says, “I like to tell people use encryption for recipes and bad jokes — especially bad jokes: this may sound silly, but it protects dissenters who need to use encryption by making their communication less conspicuous.”
Share

Related posts

January 29, 2014

US Sanctions Law Shuts Down Online Courses in #Iran


Read more
September 9, 2013

#Iran: Can Word Games Lead to Action and Real Change


Read more
September 4, 2013

#Iran–I Want My Google Play


Read more

Sign the Petition

Do your part to lift the pain of sanctions on Iranian families.

Sign Now
531 signatures

Assign a Payment Channel for Medication, Humanitarian Needs, and Non-Sanctioned Items

Dear Catherine Ashton:

We, the undersigned, are concerned about the effects the implementation of sanctions are having on average Iranians. We are particularly concerned that items that are not sanctioned, such as medication and humanitarian goods are not reaching the people in Iran.

This is a time of great suffering in the region. We want to ensure that we are not further contributing to the suffering because of the denial of access to a payment channel for humanitarian items. We know the intention of the sanctions is to put pressure on Iran’s ruling elite. We worry that this is not the reality.

The brunt of the suffering falls on women and children and the most vulnerable in society. They suffer the consequences in very real ways. They lose their incomes, their homes, and their access to life-saving medication. Some of this suffering can be alleviated by facilitating the seamless implementation of the existing humanitarian exemptions. These include financial transactions related to medications, basic needs, and other items that are currently not sanctioned.

We ask the European Union to create a payment channel to accept transactions from Iran. This channel should be closely scrutinized. This will allow much needed financial transactions for medications and basic needs to take place.

It is crucial at this time when the people of Iran are desperately trying to make their own voices heard that we show we are listening. They went to the polls in an attempt to show their own government that they wanted reform and better relations with the outside world. We need to show we are listening.

Please help to avert a humanitarian disaster. Allow Iranians access to the international banking system to purchase medications and humanitarian goods.

Thank you

[signature]

 
Sign Now

Share this with your friends:

If you are on a mobile device, click here to sign the petition.
  • US Sanctions Law Shuts Down Online Courses in #Iran
    January 29, 2014
  • Infographic–Inflation, Shortages, & Sanctions in Iran
    November 18, 2013
  • #Iran: Can Word Games Lead to Action and Real Change
    September 9, 2013
  • #Iran–I Want My Google Play
    September 4, 2013
  • Reports on Sanctions
    August 22, 2013

Categories

  • Advocacy (1)
  • Articles and Posts (20)
  • Civil Society (3)
  • Editor's Choice (5)
  • infographics (1)
  • Reports (2)
  • Sanctions (61)

Tags

Ahmad Shaheed Committee of Human Rights Reporters Coursera Economy Green movment Havaar Hemophilia Center HIV/AIDS human rights ICHRI IHRDC ILO international campaign for human rights in Iran International Federation for Human Rights International Student Peace Prize iranelection Iran Human Rights Iran Primer iranquake Iransanctions IRGC Justice for Iran Medication Observatory for the Protection of Human Rights Defenders Peyman Majidzadeh political prisoners Revolutionary Guards Reza Haji Hosseini Rouhani Sanctions Shirin Ebadi State Department surveillance Tehran Bureau The Iran Human Rights Documentation Center The Observatory for the Protection of Human Rights Defenders Thomas Erdbrink UN Special Rapporteur
This campaign is an initiative of Arseh Sevom

Arseh Sevom (Third Sphere) is a non-governmental organization established in 2010 in Amsterdam, aiming to promote peace, democracy, and human rights. Human and civil rights belong to all sectors of society and to all individuals. Arseh Sevom promotes the advancement of rights for people of all beliefs, genders, ethnicities, non- violent political affiliations, and more. A key aim for Arseh Sevom is to work with individuals and organizations to amplify their actions and efforts in the promotion of civil society.